W:
2 (40%)
D:
1 (20%)
L:
2 (40%)
19 Oct 2025
Columbus Crew vs
New York Red Bulls
1-2
05 Oct 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
FC Cincinnati
0-1
28 Sep 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
New York City
2-1
21 Sep 2025
CF Montreal vs
New York Red Bulls
2-2
14 Sep 2025
Portland Timbers vs
New York Red Bulls
3-1
W:
1 (20%)
D:
0 (0%)
L:
4 (80%)
05 Oct 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
FC Cincinnati
0-1
28 Sep 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
New York City
2-1
31 Aug 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
Columbus Crew
0-1
17 Aug 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
Philadelphia Union
0-1
11 Aug 2025
New York Red Bulls vs
Real Salt Lake
0-1
W:
1 (20%)
D:
1 (20%)
L:
3 (60%)
19 Oct 2025
Columbus Crew vs
New York Red Bulls
1-2
21 Sep 2025
CF Montreal vs
New York Red Bulls
2-2
14 Sep 2025
Portland Timbers vs
New York Red Bulls
3-1
25 Aug 2025
Charlotte vs
New York Red Bulls
3-1
27 Jul 2025
Chicago Fire vs
New York Red Bulls
2-1